AMERICAN FLYER 23719 Cow Track Animated Moving Train Set Mod 1950S

( Brand: American Flyer ), ( Manufacturer Part Number: 23719 ), ( Model: AMERICAN FLYER 23719 ), ( Set Includes: Track ), ( Theme: Animation ), ( Year Manufactured: 1950 ), ( Type: Cow On Track )

Review AMERICAN FLYER Cow On Track Animated Moving 1950s Train Set Piece Mod Vtg

The **American Flyer 23719 Cow Track Animated Moving 1950s Train Set (Mod VTG)** is a meticulously crafted vintage-inspired toy train that transports collectors and enthusiasts back to the golden age of model railroading, blending nostalgia with modern precision. This exceptional set features a **fully animated, motorized cow** that ambles along the track, adding a whimsical and dynamic element to the scene, reminiscent of classic mid-century Americana. The **1950s-themed design** is evident in the sleek, retro styling of the locomotive and rolling stock, complete with vintage-inspired lettering, polished brass details, and a warm, matte finish that evokes the charm of an era when toy trains were both a beloved pastime and a symbol of American ingenuity. The **Cow Track**, a standout feature, is a cleverly engineered loop that guides the animated cow in a continuous, looping motion, creating an endlessly entertaining display for display or play. The **mod VTG (Vintage Toy Grade) version** of this set has been carefully restored or preserved to retain its original character, with authentic patina, slightly worn edges, and subtle imperfections that add to its collectible allure. The **motorized operation** is smooth and reliable, powered by a modern yet vintage-inspired electric system that ensures hours of realistic movement, whether the cow is trotting along the track or the train is pulling its classic cars through a nostalgic landscape. Perfect for display on a shelf, a dedicated model rail layout, or as a centerpiece in a retro-themed room, this set is a true treasure for train aficionados, collectors, and anyone who appreciates the artistry of mid-century toy design. Its unique combination of animation, vintage charm, and timeless appeal makes it a standout piece in any collection.

**Pros and Cons of buying a American Flyer 23719 Cow Track Animated Moving 1950s Train Set (Vintage/Modern Reissue)**

### **Pros**

1. **Nostalgic Value** This set is a classic from the 1950s, evoking memories of mid-century toy trains and American manufacturing. For collectors or enthusiasts, it represents a piece of history, especially if it s an original vintage model.

2. **High-Quality Construction** American Flyer was known for durable, well-engineered train sets. The 23719 features a cow track (a curved layout resembling a cow s shape) with animated moving parts, which suggests smooth operation and attention to detail.

3. **Collectibility** Vintage American Flyer sets, particularly those with animated features, are highly sought after by collectors. If the condition is good, it could appreciate in value over time, especially if it s a rare or complete set.

4. **Educational and Entertainment Value** Train sets like this encourage creativity, problem-solving, and imaginative play. They can be enjoyed by children and adults alike, making them a timeless gift option.

5. **Potential for Customization** If the set is a modern reissue (rather than a true vintage piece), it may be easier to find replacement parts or accessories, extending its usability.

6. **Aesthetic Appeal** The 1950s design, with its bright colors and playful cow track, has a retro charm that many find visually appealing. It stands out compared to modern, more minimalist train sets.

7. **Functionality** The animated moving parts (such as a rotating cow or other features) add interactivity, making the set more engaging than a static display.

---

### **Cons**

1. **Cost** Vintage American Flyer sets, especially those in good condition, can be expensive. A complete, working set may cost several hundred dollars or more, depending on rarity and demand. Even modern reissues can be pricey compared to contemporary train sets.

2. **Maintenance and Wear** Older sets may require occasional repairs, such as fixing loose wheels, rusty tracks, or worn-out motors. Vintage pieces might also suffer from wear over time, requiring restoration efforts.

3. **Space Requirements** The cow track layout is compact but still takes up noticeable space. If storage is limited, this could be a drawback compared to smaller or modular modern sets.

4. **Limited Availability of Parts** For vintage sets, finding replacement parts (e.g., motors, couplers, or track pieces) can be difficult. Modern reissues may have better support, but they still might not match the original s authenticity.

5. **Potential for Counterfeit or Reproductions** The collectible market for vintage American Flyer sets is flooded with replicas or poorly made knockoffs. Buyers must be cautious to verify authenticity, especially when purchasing from third-party sellers.

6. **Not Ideal for Heavy Use** While durable, vintage sets may not withstand rough handling by young children. The delicate parts could break if mishandled, leading to frustration.

7. **Modern Alternatives Exist** Contemporary train sets (e.g., Lionel, Bachmann, or Hornby) offer more advanced features like digital control, LED lighting, and easier assembly. For those prioritizing technology and convenience, these may be preferable.

---

### **Conclusion and Recommendation**

The **American Flyer 23719 Cow Track Animated Moving 1950s Train Set** is a **fantastic choice for collectors, enthusiasts, or those seeking a nostalgic, high-quality toy**. Its craftsmanship, animated features, and historical significance make it a standout piece. However, it is **not the best fit for casual buyers, families with very young children, or those who prefer modern conveniences**.

#### **Who Should Buy It?**

- **Vintage train collectors** looking to add a rare or iconic piece to their collection.

- **Adults or older children** who appreciate retro design and can handle maintenance.

- **Gift-givers** who want a unique, heirloom-quality present for train-loving individuals.

- **Those willing to invest in a long-term hobby** and enjoy the process of restoring or preserving the set.

#### **Who Should Avoid It?**

- **Budget-conscious buyers** who can find similar functionality in more affordable modern sets.

- **Parents of very young children** who may not handle the set gently.

- **Those who prioritize digital features** (e.g., remote control, sound effects) over mechanical charm.

- **Buyers who dislike hunting for parts or restoring vintage items**.

If you **value authenticity, craftsmanship, and nostalgia** over modern convenience, this set is a **worthwhile purchase**, especially if you find a well-preserved vintage example or an authentic modern reissue. However, **verify the set s condition, authenticity, and seller reputation** before buying to avoid disappointment. For most casual train enthusiasts, a **modern American Flyer or Lionel set with similar animated features** might offer better value without the maintenance hassles.

Would you like guidance on where to buy or how to authenticate the set?

Details:

Very good condition 1950s original It MOOOOOOVES.

part #: 23719 price

• $49.95

specifications oscaletraini:

• brand: American Flyer
• mpn: 23719
• model: American Flyer 23719
• set includes: Track
• theme: Animation
• year manufactured: 1950
• type: Cow On Track

returns oscaletraini:

• method: Money back
• paid by: Buyer
• policy: Returns Accepted
• time: 14 Days

seller oscaletraini:

• rating: 99.7%
• city: Jonesboro, Georgia
• # reviews: 816

general oscaletraini:

• Railroads Trains > Parts Accessories > Buildings, Tunnels Bridges
• condition: Used

offer oscaletraini:

• started: May 26, 2026
• availability: In Stock
• quantity: 1
• sold: 0
• best offers: True
• options: Ship-to-home

payments oscaletraini:

• credit card: Mastercard
• other
• wallet: Google-pay

shipping oscaletraini:

• carrier: USPS
• cost: $6.25
• type: Fixed
• transit: 3-9 Days
• service: USPS Ground Advantage
• class: Standard

American Flyer 23719 Is Similar To:

• 01305551t American Flyer O Gauge 1680 (36.2% similar) It is being sold in as condition. No box included. Featured is a American Flyer prewar set with loco and three passenger cars. It is in very good condition, the set has been tested and works properly...(December 27th, 2016)
• 023924498067 Lionel Ac Gilbert American Flyer Sawmill New In (27.3% similar) Take a look at the pics to see condition. From a large o gauge collection comes this Flyer sawmill, Lionel 6-49806IT is in very good condition with the box. There is lot more to come. There is sun discoloration on the plastic clam shell...(August 22nd, 2018)
• 11-120-1107-1108 American Flyer Clockwork Tender Passenger (39.4% similar) American Flyer 11 early clock work locomotive w 120 tender cars. This scarce prewar set is in very good all original condition. Please see the above and pictures for imp...(January 5th, 2019)
• 1283 American Flyer Lines Model Train Transformer Free Usa (46.7% similar) See pictures. Up for sale is an American Flyer lines model 1283 train transformer - freesias...(February 27th, 2018)
• 1741 American Flyer Pre-war 401 (32.7% similar) The lead and trailing trucks 1 driver are laminating. Finally, one car is in nice condition while the other has a bit of peeling paint on bottom and could us cleaning. The other looks like a retro to me. Please see all the pictures. As well the retainer ties are present on one car but missing other...(September 3rd, 2017)
• 20-4151 Mth Rare Prototype 2 Car 70 Madison Passenger American Freedom Train (25.8% similar) Hand written number code on bottom if shown see photos. This is an o scale rare math prototype 2 car 70' Madison comb din passenger set American freedom train. This is the production sample that was used to approve disapprove the design before it was put into production. Approval disapproval tag ...(April 30th, 2016)
• 311131 American Flyer Vintage Gauge Tin Litho Gondola Sand Car (39.7% similar) Excellent condition with just a couple of small scratches on the paint as noted in pictures. Vintage o gauge American Flyer tin lithe gondola sand car 's...(April 3rd, 2018)
• 3112 1360 1306 1205 American Flyer 1925-28 Electic 3112 (32.8% similar) Never ran or tried to, been strictly on the shelf, still has dust to prove that. Appears all original parts and pieces. No surprises. Another set i've had since early eighties. Train collectors association member for since let me know and I will hold, adjust or what ever to save some shipping cash. ...(March 8th, 2017)
• 3116 3180 3182 3116 3180 American Flyer (23.7% similar) Both are lighted, however neither has a light bulb inside. Rookie tan green Bud late 1920S set with st Paul locomotive and cars. Train collectors association member for since Potomac cars, in rookie tan and green: club car enamel with brass plates, window frame trim is the observation. The motor is ...(March 24th, 2017)
• 325ac American Flyer Trains No (40.4% similar) American Flyer trains no...(March 18th, 2017)
• 32661 American Flyer Ho Pike-master (36.8% similar) C-3: poor requires major body repair for may have minor parts replaced. Visit often for great stuff. For C-9: factory new-brand new all original, unused, may evidence rubs and the slightest of handling, shipping having been test run at. Heavily scratched, major rust and missing parts. C-2: ...(December 19th, 2017)